LISBON — Lengthy earlier than the coronavirus swept throughout Europe this spring, many cities had been complaining {that a} proliferation of short-term residence leases geared toward vacationers by way of platforms like Airbnb was driving up housing prices for locals and destroying the character of historic districts.
Now that the pandemic has all however lower off the regular movement of holiday makers, many European cities are seizing a possibility to push short-term leases again onto the long-term housing market.
In Lisbon, the Portuguese capital, the town authorities is turning into a landlord itself by renting empty flats and subletting them as backed housing. In Barcelona, Spain, the housing division is threatening to take possession of empty properties and do the identical.
Different metropolis governments are enacting or planning new legal guidelines to curb the explosive development of leases aimed largely at vacationers. Amsterdam has banned trip leases within the coronary heart of the outdated metropolis; a Berlin official warned of a crackdown on short-term leasing platforms “attempting to evade regulation and the enforcement of legislation”; and Paris is planning a referendum on Airbnb-type listings.
For years, properties rented out for short-term stays have snatched away housing items from native residents in a number of European cities. Lisbon has greater than 22,000 Airbnb listings, in line with Inside Airbnb, which tracks listings in cities across the globe. Barcelona has 18,000, and Paris — one of many platform’s largest markets — has practically 60,000.
When vacationers are plentiful, renting a property on a short-term foundation may be extra profitable for homeowners than a long-term tenant, one thing that metropolis governments say has distorted housing markets in cities the place provide is already tight. In addition they accuse on-line platforms of circumventing legal guidelines put in place to guard native markets.
“We can not tolerate that lodging that could possibly be rented to Parisians are actually rented all 12 months to vacationers,” the deputy mayor of Paris, Ian Brossat, stated in a cellphone interview. Mr. Brossat additionally stated he hoped to chop the variety of days per 12 months {that a} property may be rented by way of platforms like Airbnb — presently 120. He accused the corporate of breaching even that rule.
“Airbnb pretends to respect the legislation, nevertheless it’s not the case,” stated Mr. Brossat, who has written a e book important of Airbnb and its affect on cities.
Airbnb denies any wrongdoing, in Paris or elsewhere. “They’ve set the principles, and we’re following the principles,” stated Patrick Robinson, Airbnb’s director of public coverage for Europe, the Center East and Africa. “The place there’s a vigorous dialogue about the appropriate laws, we’re a part of that dialog, and finally that’s for native politicians to determine.”
He stated that Airbnb offered registration particulars and different knowledge to the authorities in main tourism hubs like Lisbon, Paris and Barcelona to assist metropolis officers implement their guidelines. “We truly assume that higher entry to knowledge is the answer right here.” In September, the corporate launched Metropolis Portal, which it says will enable governments entry to knowledge that may assist determine listings that don’t adjust to native laws, equivalent to unregistered listings.
Essentially the most bold initiative is arguably the one in Lisbon, which has began signing five-year leases for empty short-term rental flats. These properties are then sublet at decrease costs to individuals eligible for backed housing. The town authorities has put aside Four million euros, or about $4.7 million, for the primary 12 months of subsidies.
“We entered the pandemic with an enormous stress on our housing market, and we can not afford to exit the pandemic with the identical set of issues,” stated the town’s mayor, Fernando Medina. “This program will not be a magic wand, however it may be a part of the answer by way of elevating the availability of reasonably priced housing.”
This system is aiming to draw 1,000 residence homeowners this 12 months, and has drawn 200 to date. Mr. Medina stated he was assured that the plan would meet its aim, since a rebound in tourism anytime quickly appears more and more unlikely because the pandemic drags on.
The plan has been welcomed by some neighborhood associations that had criticized native politicians as permitting the town to turn into a playground for vacationers and rich buyers, lots of them drawn to Portugal by residency permits and tax breaks provided to foreigners after the 2007-Eight monetary disaster.
“The coronavirus has helped expose the damaging facets of Portugal’s restoration from the monetary disaster, which was pushed by actual property and tourism moderately than a deal with the fundamental wants of native individuals,” stated Luís Mendes, an city geographer who’s a member of a residents’ platform known as Residing in Lisbon.
Above all, Mr. Mendes stated, the lockdown restrictions used to include the coronavirus put the highlight on the housing imbalances in Lisbon. “How are you going to quarantine when you don’t have an honest home?” he stated. “We now have a metropolis corridor that has put ahead an attention-grabbing scheme and is at the least conscious that having a roof is a basic human proper.”
Nonetheless, some householders don’t contemplate the town authorities a dependable tenant. Portugal, they are saying, has a historical past of authorized uncertainty and sudden rule modifications at any time when a brand new administration takes workplace.
“If you happen to have a look at the monitor report of the politicians in Lisbon, it’s a completely hopeless one, of incompetence and infrequently corruption,” stated Rita Alves Machado, who owns three empty short-term flats round Lisbon. “The town owes cash in all places, and I simply don’t imagine they may pay on time or stick with their very own guidelines.”
The regulation of short-term leases has been a drawn-out affair in Europe.
In September, the European Court docket of Justice backed cities trying to crack down on short-term leases, after supporting a French courtroom ruling in opposition to two property homeowners illegally renting out second houses on Airbnb. The courtroom had issued a ruling in Airbnb’s favor final 12 months, saying that it was an on-line platform moderately than an actual property firm, which might have required it to adjust to housing legal guidelines. The European Fee is taking additional steps to manage the platform and others by way of a brand new Digital Providers Act, which goals to modernize the authorized framework for such companies throughout the European Union.
The longer the pandemic hinders journey, the extra doubtless initiatives like Lisbon’s are to achieve traction, metropolis officers and native property consultants say. Within the meantime, Airbnb has discovered itself on shifting floor.
In Lisbon, occupancy charges for Airbnb and Vrbo, a short-rental reserving web site that was as soon as often called HomeAway, dropped 50 % in Could from a 12 months earlier, in line with AirDNA, which collects trip rental knowledge.
Miguel Tilli, the co-founder of HomeLovers, a Portuguese actual property company, stated he had been itemizing as many as 60 new properties a month in Lisbon — nearly all of which had beforehand been rented by way of Airbnb however have been now open to long-term tenants.
Rental costs within the metropolis have dropped 10 % because the begin of the pandemic, however landlords who had beforehand let properties by way of Airbnb have been nonetheless immune to decreasing rents.
“Many landlords are performing as if Covid is any person’s else downside,” Mr. Tilli stated. “That can’t final ceaselessly.”
Raphael Minder reported from Lisbon, and Geneva Abdul from Paris.
Discussion about this post